The Great ICP Lie: Why Your Pipeline Strategy Is Broken [And How You Can Fix It]

Episode Deep Dive

Your pipeline strategy is built on lies.

Most sales teams are living a lie.

They think they've got their ICP figured out. They've got their firmographic data, their tech stack signals, and their funding alerts all lined up.

But here's the brutal truth:

Everything starts with your ICP, but most teams are starting with the wrong foundation. They're building on quicksand, using outdated methods that worked five years ago but are now destroying their conversion rates.

Think about it. 

You're running after companies just because they use Salesforce and Gmail… because they hit a certain employee count or got their Series B.

That's not strategy. That's guesswork. 

And in 2025, guesswork is crushing your chances of success.

Here's what's actually happening in the trenches:

• Teams are blasting 45,000 emails per week (yes, per week)
• Getting a pathetic 1% reply rate
• And only 0.3% positive responses

And here’s what that means:

To hit a $5M revenue target for a $30K ACV product, you need to target 180,000 companies per quarter.

This isn't a pipeline strategy. 

It's spam at scale.

And it's killing your credibility.

Let's break down what's actually happening in the buyer's journey:

• 70% are totally unaware they have a problem
• 20% know the problem exists but aren't prioritizing it
• 7% are actively considering solutions
• 3% are ready to buy

But you're spraying and praying, hoping something sticks.

Most teams are stuck using outdated targeting methods:

• Relying purely on firmographic data
• Chasing surface-level tech signals
• Making assumptions based on funding rounds
• Sending generic messages at scale

This approach is failing because it ignores one fundamental truth: Just because a company looks like your customers doesn't mean they have the problems your solution solves.

Forget everything you know about ICPs. Here's what actually works in 2025:

1. Value Scenarios Over Vanity Metrics

Stop looking at what companies have.

Start identifying what problems they're facing.

Use AI to spot patterns of actual pain points.

Build proof-based targeting models.

2. Problem-First Targeting

Map out specific pain indicators.

Look for combinations of metrics that signal real issues.

Focus on companies showing active signs of struggle.

Build messaging around proven pain points.

3. Precision Over Volume

Forget mass outreach.

Focus on the ones actually suffering.

Build targeted, problem-specific campaigns.

Use data to validate suffering before reaching out.

Not just people that you may be able to help just because they look like your other customers.

To succeed in 2025, you need two things right:

• What's your bullseye? 
• What are you shooting at it? 

If either one is off, you're just adding to the noise.

Stop being part of the spam epidemic. Start being part of the solution. Focus on finding real problems, not checking boxes on a firmographic wishlist.

The companies crushing it in 2025 aren't the ones with the biggest lead lists or the most automated sequences. They're the ones who've mastered the art of finding and solving real problems.

Stop assuming. 

Start proving. 

Build a pipeline strategy based on actual pain, not superficial signals.

The market's changing. Are you?

Learn Mark Kosoglow's Formula for Fueling Hard Work with Fun